Europe

‘Impartial probe required’ to clarify Greek shipwreck’s disparities

An independent as well as objective examination is quickly required to make clear the plain variations in between the accounts of the survivors of the fatal Pylos shipwreck as well as those of the Greek authorities, Amnesty International as well as Human Rights Watch stated onThursday

A delegation standing for both NGOs took a trip to Greece in between 4 as well as 13 July as component of continuous study right into the conditions of the 14 June Adriana shipwreck. Of the 750 individuals approximated to be taking a trip aboard, just 104 made it through.

ADVERTISEMENT

According to testaments of the survivors collected by the 2 NGOs, the vessel was hauled by a Hellenic Coast Guard rescue watercraft, triggering it to persuade as well as tip over– declares the Greek authorities have actually highly rejected.

Survivors additionally stated that guests asked to be saved, which they experienced others on the watercraft beg to be saved by satellite phone in the hrs prior to their watercraft tipped over.

But elderly authorities of the Hellenic Coast Guard refuted this, informing both NGOs throughout a conference that those aboard just asked for food as well as water as well as revealed their objective to continue toItaly They stated the Coast Guard vessel resembled the Adriana as well as utilized ropes to come close to the watercraft to examine whether guests desired assistance, however that guests tossed the rope back as well as the watercraft proceeded its trip.

“The variations in between survivors’ accounts of the Pylos shipwreck as well as the authorities’ variation of the occasions are very worrying,” said Judith Sunderland, Associate Europe and Central Asia Director at Human Rights Watch.

“The Greek authorities, with support and scrutiny from the international community, should ensure that there is a transparent investigation to provide truth and justice for survivors and families of the victims, and hold those responsible to account.”  

Independent investigation critical

The tragedy prompted members of the European Parliament to call last month for a new EU-wide search and rescue mission in the Mediterranean to prevent more loss of life.

Frontex, the EU border agency, has also come under fire for shortcomings in its rescue response. The EU Ombudsman has since launched a formal investigation into Frontex’s response.

Greek authorities have opened two criminal investigations into the alleged smugglers and the coast guard. 

The two NGOs today called for these investigations to comply with international human rights standards of impartiality, independence, and effectiveness. They also called for the judicial investigations to be under the supervision of the Supreme Court Prosecutor’s Office and for the Greek Ombudsman’s office to be provided with the necessary resources to carry out its functions.

The NGOs claim the recent disaster adds to Greece’s ” historical failing to make sure liability for fierce as well as illegal pushbacks at the nation’s boundaries” and ” elevates worries over their capacity as well as determination to accomplish efficient as well as independent examinations.”

Greek response under scrutiny

EU Home Affairs Commissioner Ylva Johansson recently said that member states should be trusted with judicial investigations. Speaking in the European Parliament, she said that ” there is an immediate demand for an extensive, clear as well as efficient examination, as well as I concur that this is very important for numerous factors, not the very least for the Greek track record.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The NGOs claim a complete examination must look for to “clarify any responsibility for both the sinking of the ship and delays or shortcomings in the rescue efforts that may have contributed to the appalling loss of life.”

Amnesty International as well as Human Rights Watch stated they will certainly proceed their very own examination as well as prompted Brussels to modify its movement plans.

“This preventable tragedy demonstrates the bankruptcy of EU migration policies predicated on the racialized exclusion of people on the move and deadly deterrence,” stated Esther Major, Amnesty International’s Senior Research Adviser for Europe.

“To ensure this is the last, and not the latest, in an unconscionably long list of tragedies in the Mediterranean, the EU should reorient its border policies towards rescue at sea and safe and legal routes for asylum seekers, refugees and migrants.”

Read the complete post here

.

What’s your Reaction?
+1
0
+1
0
+1
0
+1
0
+1
0
+1
0
+1
0
Back to top button