Israel coalition talks: Eisenkot gets first chance to form government after Netanyahu setback
JERUSALEM — Israel’s post-election bargaining has entered a consequential phase after President Isaac Herzog gave opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot the first opportunity to form a government. The move is a setback for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, whose bloc failed to secure a governing majority in the Oct. 27 election. It is not yet proof that Netanyahu is leaving office: coalition talks can fail, and the next government depends on agreements among parties with sharply different priorities.
Herzog’s announcement on Nov. 7 followed consultations with party representatives. The president’s role is procedural but important: he asks a member of Knesset judged most likely to assemble support to form a coalition. Eisenkot, a former military chief and leader of the Yashar party, now has a limited period to negotiate. The Associated Press report says the Oct. 27 vote left the anti-Netanyahu camp with a path to a majority, while the governing bloc came up short.
The arithmetic is only the first hurdle
Israel’s 120-seat Knesset requires a majority of 61 members to sustain a government. Opposition parties have discussed cooperation across a wide ideological range, including Arab-led parties. That possibility is politically significant: Arab parties have often been excluded from governing coalitions, although the Ra’am party supported the 2021 government from outside and the broader Arab party system has varied across elections.
Eisenkot needs more than a shared desire to replace Netanyahu. The parties must agree on a cabinet, budget priorities, military service, judicial reform, the conduct of the war and the status of Arab citizens. Some leaders oppose direct coalition partnership with Arab parties; others argue that excluding them ignores the votes of millions of citizens and makes a stable majority impossible. Agreement on one issue does not ensure agreement on the next.
Political reporting says Arab lawmaker Ahmad Tibi has signalled willingness to break with precedent if a coalition commits to common policy goals. The AP profile of Tibi describes the political tension behind that offer and the deep suspicion many Jewish Israelis have historically directed at Arab parties. That background should not obscure the basic democratic fact that Arab citizens vote and their elected representatives hold seats in the Knesset.
What a new government could change
If Eisenkot succeeds, the first visible change would be leadership, not an instant resolution of Israel’s security and social crises. A new coalition would face pressure to set a strategy for the war, protect civilians, address the return of hostages and decide how to deal with international partners. It would also confront disagreements over military conscription exemptions for ultra-Orthodox men, the independence of the judiciary and the relationship between religious parties and the state.
The opposition’s unity is partly negative—opposition to Netanyahu—and partly substantive. Netanyahu’s critics argue that his government weakened institutions, failed to prevent the Oct. 7 attack and mishandled the ensuing war. Netanyahu’s supporters say he has pursued Israel’s security in exceptionally difficult conditions and warn that a coalition relying on Arab parties would endanger the country. These are competing political arguments, not established descriptions of what a future coalition will do.
Economic choices will also matter. A coalition could face the costs of prolonged conflict, reserve mobilization and recovery in affected communities. Its budget would have to balance security spending with services, housing and reconstruction. Since coalition partners can threaten to leave, the composition of the cabinet may determine which commitments are realistic.
Why the next few days matter
The mandate to try first is not a guarantee. If Eisenkot cannot assemble a majority, the process may move to another lawmaker or ultimately return the country to another election. Party leaders may also negotiate confidence-and-supply arrangements or outside support rather than formal cabinet posts. The precise path depends on parliamentary rules and the president’s subsequent decisions.
For Israel’s Arab citizens, the coalition debate is about representation as well as power. For Jewish voters, it is entangled with questions of security, national identity and whether a government dependent on Arab parties can act effectively during wartime. Any coverage that treats Arab voters as a single bloc or describes them as inherently disloyal reproduces political rhetoric rather than reporting evidence.
The election has opened a negotiating window, not closed a chapter. The clearest measure of what is changing will be the final coalition agreement: its signatories, policy commitments and votes of confidence. Until then, headlines about a “new government” should be read as a possibility under negotiation. Netanyahu remains prime minister while the process continues, and a stable transfer of power would require the constitutional and parliamentary steps that follow any successful coalition deal.
Those negotiations also carry consequences beyond the Knesset. A government’s position on the war, settlement policy and humanitarian access will influence Israel’s relations with allies and regional partners. Coalition partners may seek quick symbolic changes, while security officials and diplomats urge continuity or caution. The public should judge the next cabinet by its actions and published decisions, not merely by the identity of the person who receives the mandate to negotiate.



